From Justin to Kelly

Listeners Choice Month comes to an end with the final pick as listener Gabe has given them one of Nathan’s favourite genres – the musical. Yes, it’s the 2003 contractually-obligated smash hit From Justin to Kelly. The guys break it all down and talk about the least memorable musical numbers in human existence, beach-beds, the evolution of text messaging, the massive amount of “filler” (in an 81-minute movie), a needlessly convoluted hoverboard competition, Nathan analyzes the art of “soap opera name-dropping” and much more. Plus: WILL SOMEONE JUST HAVE A REAL CONVERSATION ALREADY!?


The guys also drop a hint for next week’s movie. Check on Facebook or Twitter on Monday for the reveal!



What We’ve Been Watching:


Boss Level



Questions? Comments? Suggestions? You can always shoot us an e-mail at 







Theme Song recorded by Taylor Sheasgreen:

Logo designed by Mariah Lirette:

Montrose Monkington III:


Head over to and check out some wonderful art by friend of the show Izzy Fischer! Use the promo code “wwttpod” to receive 15% off your purchase!


What Were They Thinking is sponsored by and HostGator (use the coupon code ‘SCHLOCK’ for 25% off your first purchase) and is a proud member of the Age of Radio Podcast Network (


From Justin to Kelly stars Justin Guarini, Kelly Clarkson, Anika Noni Rose, Katherine Bailess, Gregory Siff, Brian Dietzen and Jason Yribar; directed by Robert Iscove.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit

Share This